Season 4 kicked off with a “second chances” twist. 3 returning players from season 2 (Shannon, Scott and Jessica) and 11 new players. This was the last season the random veto draw was used for veto comps. This season also brought the first tied, the first female RRBB winner and the only even numbered jury.
Day 1 Jamie won HoH nominating Coltonand Gregory. Colton won veto and after removing himself Bobby was the replacement nominee and ultimately evicted in an 8-3 vote. Day 2 Kevin won HoH nominating Gregory and Prince. Kevin won HoH and kept the nominations the same sealing Gregory’s fate and he was evicted unanimously.
Day 3 TA won HoH and she decided to keep blood off her hands by nominating Coltonand Prince. Pandora’s Box was brought into play and was opened causing two additional nominees to go on the block, Scott and Jessica joined the other two nominees. Susan won veto and did not use it. By a vote of 3-2-1-0 Colton was evicted from the game but it would not be for long! It was time for a double eviction! Shannon won HoH and nominated Kevin and Susan. Thomas won veto and removed Kevin. Shannon then nominated Scott as replacement and he was evicted 6-2.
Day 4 Jamie won HoH and nominated Shannon and Kevin. Kevin won veto and saved himself and Jamie nominated Thomas in his place. Shannon was evicted in the second unanimous vote of the seaon 7-0.
Day 5 the “Second Chances” twist brought Colton back into the game and made him HoH. Colton nominated Melissa and Jessica for eviction. Jamie won veto and used it on Melissa. Colton put Kevin on the block sealing his fate in the game and he was evicted 6-1.
Day 6 Thomas won HoH, nominating Jamie and Melissa. Colton won veto and Jamie used her charm and excellent social game convincing him to use it on her. Jen was the replacement nominee and Melissa was evicted by a vote of 3-2 and was the first member of jury.
After eviction Jessica announced that she needed to leave the game due to personal reasons. Since this left jury short a member, Kevin was brought back to join jury.
Day 7 Prince won HoH and nominated TA and Jamie for eviction. Thomas won veto and Jamie once again charmed her way off the block. Susan was nominated as the replacement and this eviction resulted in the first ever RRBB tie 2-2! Prince broke the tie by sending TA off to jury.
Day 8 Thomas won HoH and he nominated Prince and Colton. Thomas also won veto and kept his nominations the same resulting in the third unanimous vote (3-0) of the season and sealing Colton’s fate in the game.
Day 9 Susan won HoH and she nominated Thomas and Jamie. Jamie won veto saving herself from eviction. Susan had a tough time deciding who to put up as a replacement nomination between Jen and Prince. Jen promised Susan that she would not evict Prince if Susan kept her off the block. Unfortunately this was not the case and Prince was sent to jury. After this Susan deactivated her twitter and disappeared without a trace. This fast forwarded the game to final 3.
Jamie ultimately won final HoH sending Jen off to jury. Jamie won the game by a 4-2 vote and was the first female winner of RRBB!